Are Home Prices Crashing Worse Than 2008?

Are Home Prices Crashing Worse Than 2008?

The Rate Update with Dan Frio
1 Application • 1 Credit Pull • 30+ Lenders
Updated: October 7, 2025

Are Home Prices Crashing Worse Than 2008?

Short answer: No. The 2008 era saw national prices fall much further and for longer. Today’s pullbacks are real but localized, and the broad indexes remain far from a systemic collapse.

National Peak→Trough (2006–2012)−27%
Case‑Shiller 20‑City Composite−35%
Worst Large‑Metro Pullbacks (2022→2025)−10% to −24%
Recent National YoY TrendPositive

Sources: S&P CoreLogic Case‑Shiller; CoreLogic repeat‑sales; author synthesis through Jul–Aug 2025.

When the 2008 Crash Began

Peak: July 2006 (national). Trough: ~Feb–Mar 2012. Foreclosures and forced sales amplified declines in the “bubble” metros.

Top 5 Peak→Trough Declines (2006–2012)

MetroApprox. DeclineNotes
Las Vegas, NV−61%Case‑Shiller
Phoenix, AZ−56%Case‑Shiller
Riverside–San Bernardino, CA−54%CoreLogic repeat‑sales
Miami, FL−50%Case‑Shiller
Tampa, FL−46%Case‑Shiller

Nationally: −27% (Case‑Shiller national); 20‑City Composite: −35%.

2021–Today (Latest Data)

Post‑pandemic peaks were mostly in 2022. Since then, multiple markets cooled—especially prior high‑flyers. The worst large‑metro drawdowns have been single‑digit to low‑double‑digit.

Notable Peak→Current Pullbacks (2022→2025)

MetroApprox. ChangeNotes
Austin, TX~−24%Outside CS‑20; metro trackers
San Francisco, CA~−11%Case‑Shiller
Phoenix, AZ~−10%Case‑Shiller trend
Oakland/East Bay, CA~−20% to −24%Bay Area trackers
Tampa, FL−2% to −4% YoY mid‑2025Case‑Shiller YoY

National and CS‑20 indexes recently remain modestly positive year‑over‑year; monthly prints have softened.

Featured Media Appearances — Dan Frio in the News

Connect with Dan • Apply • Book

Everything in one place — subscribe for updates, start your application, or grab time on the calendar. Follow on social to catch live rate moves and strategy videos.

Let us help you!

Our representative will be in touch with you.

* Specific loan program availability and requirements may vary. Please get in touch with your mortgage advisor for more information.