Trump’s 401(k) Down Payment Plan Exposes a Big Homebuying Myth

TRU

Using Your 401(k) for a Down Payment

A practical comparison: today’s rules vs. what’s being proposed — plus realistic down‑payment math.

Audience: Homebuyers & HomeownersTopic: 401(k) funds + down paymentDisclaimer: Educational only

Rules Today vs. Proposed (Trump)

Policy details may change; treat “Proposed” as TBD until enacted.

Feature	Today (Current 401(k) Rules)	Proposed (Trump Plan – as discussed)
Using 401(k) money for a down payment	Generally possible only through: (1) a 401(k) loan (if your plan allows it) or (2) an early withdrawal (typically taxed and penalized if under 59½).	Would allow using 401(k) savings specifically for a down payment under a defined “qualified home purchase” framework.
10% early‑withdrawal penalty (under 59½)	Usually applies for early distributions unless a specific IRS exception applies (401(k) home purchase is typically not an exception).	Potentially reduced/waived for qualified down‑payment withdrawals (details and caps TBD).
Income tax on the money withdrawn	Usually applies to distributions (ordinary income). Loans are not taxed if repaid per plan rules.	TBD — may be taxed, partially taxed, or deferred depending on final legislative language.
401(k) loan option	Common option if your plan allows it. Borrow up to IRS limits (often the lesser of $50,000 or 50% of vested balance). Must repay; job change can accelerate repayment.	Likely unchanged — proposal focuses on withdrawals for down payments, not replacing the loan feature.
Applies to every 401(k) plan?	No — especially for loans/hardship withdrawals; plan rules vary by employer and provider.	TBD — depends on whether it’s written as a universal federal rule or still relies on plan‑level options.
Proof that funds are for a home	Plan administrators may require documentation for hardship withdrawals; loans typically do not require “home proof” unless plan demands it.	Likely requires documentation (purchase contract, settlement statement, etc.) to qualify for special treatment.
Big picture trade‑off	Using retirement funds can reduce long‑term compounding; 401(k) loans can also disrupt growth while borrowed.	Could make access easier up front, but still carries long‑term retirement opportunity cost.

Note: exact proposal caps, eligibility, and tax treatment have not been finalized publicly in a single enacted rule as of this writing.

Typical 401(k) Savings (Averages by Age)

Averages can be skewed higher than “typical” (median) due to higher‑balance savers.

Ages 30–34 (Average 401(k) balance)

$42,640

Useful for context when someone claims “most buyers in their 30s have huge 401(k)s.”

Ages 35–44 (Average 401(k) balance)

$103,552

Balances vary widely; many households are far below the average.

Down‑Payment Misconceptions (What You Really Need)

Examples are simplified; eligibility depends on credit, income, property, and program.

Myth: “You need $50,000–$100,000 down to buy a $400,000 home.”

Reality: Many buyers can qualify with 3% down (common for first‑time buyers on certain conventional programs) or 5% down for many non‑first‑time conventional scenarios.

Example: $400,000 home @ 3% down

$12,000

Calculation: $400,000 × 0.03 = $12,000

Example: $400,000 home @ 5% down

$20,000

Calculation: $400,000 × 0.05 = $20,000

Closing costs are a separate bucket from down payment (lender fees, title/escrow, prepaid taxes/insurance, etc.).
In many transactions, seller concessions can help cover some or most closing costs — depending on your contract, market conditions, and loan program rules.
Bottom line: the “required cash to close” is often far less than the 20% down myth suggests.

Next Steps

Get guidance tailored to your scenario.

RateWatch 2.1 — Get Alerts Schedule a Consultation Ask Dan a Question Apply Now (One App • One Credit Pull)